Integrating Disability Studies Into Existing Curriculum
by: Rose Sachs, LCSW-C
Montgomery
College
Montgomery County,
Maryland
http://www.montgomerycollege.edu/Departments/dispsvc/diversity.htm
|
Individuals
with disabilities comprise approximately one-fifth of the total
population in the United States (U.S. Bureau of Census, 1994-95), the
nation's largest minority group. And yet, people with disabilities
continue to be excluded from discourse on difference and diversity.
People with disabilities are viewed neither as a minority group from the
perspective of that which constitutes and defines minority nor as a
minority group from the perspective of how cultural institutions
produce, perpetuate, and justify hierarchal societies. Unlike members of
minorities classified by race, class, ethnicity, and gender, who are
seen as ordinary variations within the major culture, disability is
perceived as extraordinary, despite the numbers that alone would
contradict this perception. Poet and essayist, Audrey Lorde (1984),
defined herself as a Black, lesbian feminist, a member of several
minority groups; she was also disabled. In "Age, Race, Class, and
Sex," Lorde (1984) defines the outsider, the individual of minority
status, as one who differs from the major population, the desired and
mythical norm: he who is: "white, thin, male, young, heterosexual,
Christian, and financially secure." Disability is not mentioned. Although disability intersects all
other minority populations, people with disabilities have been
overlooked by, and in many cases, categorically excluded from, rights
seeking movements: the Civil Rights Movement, the Women's Movement, The
Gay Rights Movement. Moreover, in activities aimed at understanding,
accepting, and celebrating diversity, both in academia and the work
world, people with disabilities are rarely assigned minority status,
rarely included as a discrete and disenfranchised population with a
collective history, a collective experience, and a collective voice. The
purpose of this discussion is to create a foundation for viewing
disability as a minority model and a social, political, and economic
construct and to establish the integration of this paradigm into
existing curriculum at an introductory course level, particularly in a
community college environment, as a necessary component of social
change. |
|
Paradigms
of Disability |
|
Minority
Status |
|
|
|
Unique
Characteristics of Disability A critical factor that separates
persons with disabilities from other minority groups is that anyone may
join at any time; minority status may or may not be conferred at birth.
Although not the case globally, the largest population of individuals
with disabilities in the United States is the elderly. Most everyone,
then, if s/he lives long enough, will, indeed, become disabled. Because
membership is a clear and almost inevitable prospect; because the social
identity of people with disabilities is one of stigma; because people
with disabilities are devalued, discredited, and discounted, and because
the prevailing image of people with disabilities, which is internalized
by both disabled and non-disabled persons, is wholly negative, fear
evoked by disability is pervasive throughout history and across
cultures. |
|
Disability
Studies The charge, then, of Disability
Studies is to challenge and deconstruct these currently held myths,
stereotypes, assumptions, and perceptions about people with
disabilities; to examine disability within the contexts of culture and
history; to explore the shared experience of disability from a
cross-disability perspective; and to develop a view of persons with
disabilities within a minority model that reflects and honors their
collective voice. The Society for Disability Studies (2000) defines the
mission of the field as one that "encourages perspectives that
place disability in social, cultural, and political contexts" and
seeks "to augment the understanding of disability in all cultures
and historical periods, to promote greater awareness of the experiences
of disabled people, and to contribute to social change." |
|
|
|
Teaching
at the Introductory Course/Community College Level Including disability with race, class,
ethnicity, and gender promotes a realistic view of disability and a
positive attitude toward people with disabilities, which serves to
empower students with disabilities. Segregation and exclusion have been
the most damaging realities for people with disabilities; despite
current laws aimed at protecting disabled persons and mandating access
to employment, education, transportation, and public accommodations, the
history and experience of disability must be incorporated into academia
in order to dissolve the erroneous beliefs and negative attitudes that
create barriers to a full range of life's opportunities and shape the
lives of disabled persons. In addition to sociology, history, and the
humanities, the experience of people with disabilities, the assumptions
about people with disabilities, and the ways in which those assumptions
mold the treatment of people with disabilities need to be explored in
coursework in the fields of psychology, human development, law,
political science, public policy, Afro-American Studies, Hispanic
Studies, Asian Studies, Gay/Lesbian Studies, Women's Studies, as well as
history of film, theater, and art. In that popular culture both reflects
and creates societal notions, the images of persons with disabilities
needs to be incorporated in courses that examine the media:
advertisement, television, and journalism. |
|
Teaching
Models The experience of individuals with
disabilities needs to be integrated into history courses wherever
minority experiences are taught. In addition to examining the major
events and influences concerning disability and disability activism,
such as the Independent Living Movement, the Disability Rights Movement,
and the passage of 504 of the Rehabilitation Act and ADA, past and
current impact on people with disabilities within key aspects of
American history, such as immigration restriction, citizenship, civil
rights, evolutionary theory, and eugenics needs to be incorporated as
well. The history of civil rights for
individuals with disabilities needs to be incorporated in any history
course that deals with human rights. The Disability Rights Movement
began in the early 1970's, within the same general time frame as the
Civil Rights and Women Movements. People with disabilities were closing
down buildings, creating independent living centers, and protesting on
college campuses; yet, unlike issues of women, African-Americans, and
Hispanics, disability is only now emerging as an area of study. Women with disabilities have a much
lower rate of social and economic success than non-disabled women and
than disabled men. Women with disabilities have traditionally been
excluded from the examination of both women's issues and issues of
persons with disabilities, as well as from their human rights efforts.
The experience of women with disabilities needs to be incorporated in
Women's Studies courses. Additionally, the cultural value of body image
is a key factor impacting social role determination and self-esteem for
all women. Women with disabilities fare particularly poorly within this
construct; moreover, historically, women have been disabled by
cultural-specific practices employed in an effort to create the ideal
body. Courses in literature need to include
the images of characters with disabilities, as well make note of the
exclusion of characters with disabilities. With few exception, disabled
characters are marginal, minor characters, rarely a main character. They
are stereotypical, metaphorical, uncomplicated, and incomplete; their
purpose is to in some way shed light on the main character or to advance
the plot. When a character with a disability is employed as a major
character, he/she emerges within two main portrayals: that of the
monster or demon or he/she who evokes pity and charity. Moreover, the
writings of persons with disabilities in traditional genres, fiction,
nonfiction, and poetry, need to be incorporated into appropriate
courses, as do contemporary disability/body writing: memoir,
autobiography, and personal essay. Courses that cover the history of
film, theater, and art need to include individuals with disabilities.
Movies, being more accessible to the vast majority than theater and the
fine arts, tend to express and reflect mainstream cultural values.
History of film courses need include the historical and evolving images
of individuals with disabilities. Typically, disability has been
translated into personal and social inferiority. The disabled character
is not so much a character, but rather a metaphor in which disability
represents a flaw in character. Martin Norden (1994), in The Cinema of
Isolation, states that film has historically isolated disabled
characters from the mainstream and from each other. They are to be
pitied, scorned, or feared; they are childlike, magical, or demonic and
usually self-loathing. Resolution for disabled characters is either
cure, which allows them to be whole and absorbed into the mainstream, or
death. Additionally, the use of actors with disabilities needs to be
examined. History of theatre courses need to
include the historical and evolving use of disabled characters and
disabled actors in much the same way as history of film courses. An
additional area of examination in theater is the emerging and evolving
genre of theater and "physically integrated" dance that focus
on and celebrate disability. Courses in the history of the visual arts,
fine art and photography, need to examine the representation of the
disabled figure. In addition, a current movement comprised mainly of
artists with disabilities is using visual arts as a means to incorporate
the history and experience of disability into the mainstream to lend
visibility and identity to the disabled community. |
|
|
|
Conclusion Knowledge and understanding are the
seeds of change and the tools of empowerment. Thus far, educators have
been sorely remiss in the wholesale exclusion of the history and shared
experience of individuals with disabilities as an area of study. This
omission is significant both academically, which diminishes the breadth
and depth of education offered, and functionally, which perpetuates the
inferior status of individuals with disabilities. Inherent in the
mission of the community college is an imperative to educate and an
opportunity to affect a diverse and comprehensive population of
students. Our responsibility as educators who have accepted this mission
and who value this opportunity is to commit as active participants to
the inclusion of Disability Studies as both content and process within
our classrooms. |
|
References
|